Socially Responsible Investing (SRI) vs. Traditional Investing: A Performance Comparison

Socially Responsible Investing (SRI) vs. Traditional Investing: A Performance Comparison

Introduction

Investing has long been a popular way for individuals and institutions to grow their wealth. However, with the rise of socially responsible investing (SRI), many investors are questioning the impact of their investments on the world around them. In this article, we will compare the performance of traditional investing with SRI and explore the benefits and drawbacks of each approach.

Traditional Investing vs. Socially Responsible Investing

Traditional investing involves investing in companies that are not held accountable for their social or environmental impact. This approach is focused solely on maximizing returns for investors. On the other hand, SRI involves investing in companies that are committed to responsible practices and have a positive impact on society and the environment.

Performance Comparison

When it comes to performance, traditional investing has historically outperformed SRI. However, recent studies have shown that SRI can outperform traditional investing in the long term. This is due to the fact that SRI investors are more likely to hold onto their investments for the long term, which can lead to better returns.

One study by the University of California, Berkeley, found that SRI funds outperformed traditional funds over a 15-year period. Another study by the University of Pennsylvania found that SRI funds outperformed traditional funds over a 20-year period.

However, it's important to note that the performance of SRI can vary depending on the specific fund and the time period. Some SRI funds may underperform traditional funds in certain market conditions, while others may outperform them.

Benefits of Socially Responsible Investing

In addition to potential performance benefits, there are many other benefits to socially responsible investing. SRI can help investors align their values with their investments, which can lead to a greater sense of purpose and satisfaction. It can also help reduce the risk of socially irresponsible investments, which can be harmful to the environment and society.

SRI can also help investors diversify their portfolios, as many SRI funds invest in a variety of industries and geographic regions. This can help reduce the risk of losing all of an investor's money in a single company or industry.

Drawbacks of Traditional Investing

While traditional investing has historically outperformed SRI, there are also drawbacks to this approach. Traditional investing can lead to investments in companies that are not held accountable for their social or environmental impact. This can be harmful to society and the environment, and can also lead to negative publicity for the company.

Furthermore, traditional investing can be more risky than SRI, as it is focused solely on maximizing returns for investors. This can lead to investments in companies that are not sustainable or have a high risk of failure.

Conclusion

Socially responsible investing (SRI) vs. traditional investing is a complex topic, and the best approach for an individual will depend on their specific goals and values. While traditional investing has historically outperformed SRI, recent studies have shown that SRI can outperform traditional investing in the long term.

Investors who are concerned about the impact of their investments on society and the environment should consider socially responsible investing. SRI can help investors align their values with their investments, reduce the risk of socially irresponsible investments, and diversify their portfolios.

However, it's important to note that the performance of SRI can vary depending on the specific fund and the time period. Investors should carefully research the performance of any SRI fund they are considering, and should also consider the potential drawbacks of traditional investing.

In conclusion, socially responsible investing (SRI) vs. traditional investing is a complex topic, and the best approach for an individual will depend on their specific goals and values. While traditional investing has historically outperformed SRI, recent studies have shown that SRI can outperform traditional investing in the long term.

FAQ's

What is socially responsible investing (SRI)?+

What is the difference between ESG and SRI?+

How do I start with ESG or SRI investing?+

How does SRI differ from ESG investing?+

What role does shareholder advocacy play in SRI?+

What is impact investing?+

What is the role of an insurance actuary in the insurance industry?+

How do companies use earnings to drive financial performance?+

How can companies use earnings to drive financial performance?+

What is the role of an insurance claims adjuster?+

Want financial news and market updates?

FREE Weekly Market Updates delivered to your inbox.

Market Watch
$264.24
JPM
-0.96% (-$2.56)
JPMorgan Chase & Co.
11:55 AM
$526.08
QQQ
-2.08% (-$11.15)
Invesco QQQ Trust
11:50 AM
$683.55
META
-1.62% (-$11.29)
Meta, Inc.
12:20 AM
$18.70
GFI
-2.60% (-$0.50)
Gold Fields
11:55 AM
$76.50
NKE
-0.95% (-$0.73)
Nike, Inc.
11:50 AM
$45.33
NEM
-5.74% (-$2.76)
Newmont Corporation
5:25 PM
$385.30
HD
-2.37% (-$9.34)
The Home Depot, Inc.
11:55 AM
$31.64
AU
-1.19% (-$0.38)
AngloGold Ashanti
11:50 AM
$81.54
EFA
-0.62% (-$0.51)
iShares MSCI EAFE ETF
11:50 AM
$466.42
UNH
-7.17% (-$36.00)
UnitedHealth Group Incorporated
11:55 AM
$337.80
TSLA
-4.68% (-$16.60)
Tesla, Inc.
12:00 PM
$295.40
AXP
-2.78% (-$8.46)
American Express Company
11:50 AM
$5.46
CDE
-10.49% (-$0.64)
Coeur Mining
5:10 PM
$110.84
AMD
-2.92% (-$3.33)
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc.
11:55 AM
$108.66
DIS
-1.71% (-$1.89)
The Walt Disney Company
11:50 AM
$24.87
INTC
-4.68% (-$1.22)
Intel Corporation
11:45 AM
$718750.00
BRK-A
-0.59% (-$4230.06)
Berkshire Hathaway Inc.
1:30 AM
$2.82
BTG
0.36% ($0.01)
B2Gold
12:00 PM
$179.66
GOOGL
-2.65% (-$4.90)
Alphabet Inc.
11:50 AM
$348.53
V
-0.56% (-$1.96)
Visa Inc.
11:55 AM
$625.60
GS
-2.59% (-$16.66)
The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.
12:05 PM
$156.92
CVX
-1.18% (-$1.87)
Chevron Corporation
12:05 PM
$55.39
IAU
-0.09% (-$0.05)
iShares Gold Trust
11:55 AM
$144.98
MMM
-2.75% (-$4.10)
3M Company
11:50 AM
$7.14
MUX
-6.42% (-$0.49)
McEwen Mining
12:05 PM
$11.55
SILV
-0.86% (-$0.10)
SilverCrest Metals
12:00 PM
$110.69
XOM
-1.17% (-$1.31)
Exxon Mobil Corporation
12:05 PM
$408.21
MSFT
-1.90% (-$7.92)
Microsoft Corporation
11:55 AM
$22.69
AGI
-2.49% (-$0.58)
Alamos Gold
11:50 AM
$29.59
SLV
-1.20% (-$0.36)
iShares Silver Trust
11:50 AM
$10.23
SSRM
-2.57% (-$0.27)
SSR Mining
12:05 PM
$10.97
KGC
-4.94% (-$0.57)
Kinross Gold
5:25 PM
$167.81
ORCL
-4.65% (-$8.19)
Oracle Corporation
12:00 PM
$138.69
FNV
-2.14% (-$3.04)
Franco-Nevada
11:45 AM
$71.35
KO
1.87% ($1.31)
The Coca-Cola Company
11:50 AM
$245.55
AAPL
-0.11% (-$0.28)
Apple Inc.
11:50 AM
$599.94
SPY
-1.71% (-$10.44)
SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust
11:55 AM
$216.58
AMZN
-2.83% (-$6.30)
Amazon.com, Inc.
12:55 PM
$295.92
VTI
-1.85% (-$5.57)
Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF
12:05 PM
$94.78
WMT
-2.50% (-$2.43)
Walmart Inc.
12:20 PM
$26.62
T
1.80% ($0.47)
AT&T Inc.
12:00 PM
$13.41
EGO
-8.59% (-$1.26)
Eldorado Gold
12:05 PM
$68.05
WPM
-2.72% (-$1.90)
Wheaton Precious Metals
11:50 AM
$202.08
ABBV
0.60% ($1.20)
AbbVie Inc.
12:20 PM
$24.44
PAAS
-4.16% (-$1.06)
Pan American Silver
3:55 AM
$170.23
PG
1.81% ($3.02)
The Procter & Gamble Company
11:50 AM
$304.81
MCD
0.58% ($1.76)
McDonald's Corporation
11:50 AM
$89.50
MRK
2.08% ($1.82)
Merck & Co., Inc.
12:20 PM
$18.30
GOLD
-2.76% (-$0.52)
Barrick Gold Corp.
12:00 PM
$5.22
HL
-7.28% (-$0.41)
Hecla Mining
12:05 PM
$46.40
VWO
-0.13% (-$0.06)
Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF
12:05 PM
$26.30
PFE
1.54% ($0.40)
Pfizer Inc.
12:20 PM
$42.76
VZ
0.64% ($0.27)
Verizon Communications Inc.
11:50 AM
$177.15
BA
-2.06% (-$3.73)
Boeing Company
12:15 PM
$148.45
RGLD
-2.49% (-$3.79)
Royal Gold Inc.
12:05 PM
$63.98
CSCO
-1.07% (-$0.69)
Cisco Systems, Inc.
11:55 AM
$217.80
IWM
-2.88% (-$6.46)
iShares Russell 2000 ETF
12:10 PM
$74.95
PYPL
-3.45% (-$2.68)
PayPal Holdings, Inc.
11:50 AM
$5.98
SAND
-3.39% (-$0.21)
Sandstorm Gold
12:10 PM
$40.80
GDX
-3.41% (-$1.44)
VanEck Gold Miners
11:50 AM
$270.74
GLD
-0.09% (-$0.25)
SPDR Gold Trust
11:55 AM
$5.55
AG
-3.65% (-$0.21)
First Majestic Silver
12:20 PM
$309.80
CRM
-2.71% (-$8.63)
Salesforce.com, inc.
12:00 PM
$211.94
HON
0.28% ($0.59)
Honeywell International Inc.
12:05 PM
$3.84
EXK
-7.91% (-$0.33)
Endeavour Silver
11:55 AM
$96.10
AEM
-1.98% (-$1.94)
Agnico Eagle Mines
12:00 PM
$162.30
JNJ
1.64% ($2.62)
Johnson & Johnson
3:55 AM
$557.51
MA
-1.02% (-$5.77)
Mastercard Incorporated
12:00 PM
$50.37
GDXJ
-4.04% (-$2.12)
VanEck Junior Gold Miners
12:10 PM
$134.43
NVDA
-4.05% (-$5.68)
NVIDIA Corporation
12:05 PM
$1003.15
NFLX
-2.09% (-$21.39)
Netflix, Inc.
11:55 AM
$551.75
VOO
-1.70% (-$9.55)
Vanguard S&P 500 ETF
11:55 AM
$44.90
EEM
-0.29% (-$0.13)
iShares MSCI Emerging Markets ETF
12:05 PM
$51.24
VEA
-0.72% (-$0.37)
Vanguard FTSE Developed Markets ETF
11:55 AM
$50.75
XLF
-1.25% (-$0.64)
Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund
12:05 PM
$555.86
VFIAX
-1.70% (-$9.63)
Vanguard 500 Index Fund
11:55 AM
$209.13
FXAIX
-1.70% (-$3.62)
Fidelity 500 Index Fund
12:00 PM
$144.03
VTSAX
-1.86% (-$2.73)
Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund
12:10 PM
$272.42
DODGX
-1.31% (-$3.62)
Dodge & Cox Stock Fund
12:05 PM
$76.76
AGTHX
-2.34% (-$1.84)
American Funds Growth Fund of America
12:00 PM
$188.82
TRBCX
-2.44% (-$4.72)
T. Rowe Price Blue Chip Growth Fund
12:10 PM
$20.70
BECO
0.12% ($0.02)
BlackRock Future Climate and Sustainable Economy
5:00 AM
$58.14
GLDM
-0.09% (-$0.05)
SPDR Gold MiniShares
11:55 AM
$51.63
BITB
-3.77% (-$2.02)
Bitwise Bitcoin
11:50 AM
$75.06
GBTC
-3.78% (-$2.95)
Grayscale Bitcoin
12:00 PM
$91.64
VNQ
-0.98% (-$0.91)
Vanguard Real Estate
11:50 AM
$444.32
ADBE
-2.28% (-$10.37)
Adobe Inc.
11:55 AM
$111.78
ALTR
0.00% (-$0.00)
Altair Engineering Inc.
12:05 PM
$171.98
AMAT
-2.29% (-$4.03)
Applied Materials, Inc.
11:45 AM
$303.01
AMGN
1.71% ($5.08)
Amgen Inc.
12:55 PM
$140.64
BIIB
2.60% ($3.56)
Biogen Inc.
12:00 PM
$23.00
CECO
-4.80% (-$1.16)
CECO Environmental Corp.
11:55 AM
$216.80
CHKP
-1.03% (-$2.25)
Check Point Software Technologies Ltd.
12:00 PM
$100.88
CHRW
0.46% ($0.46)
C.H. Robinson Worldwide, Inc.
12:40 PM
$36.24
CMCSA
-0.47% (-$0.17)
Comcast Corporation
12:40 PM
$1035.03
COST
0.02% ($0.20)
Costco Wholesale Corporation
12:00 PM
$204.43
CTAS
-0.73% (-$1.50)
Cintas Corporation
12:40 PM
$117.60
DELL
-1.91% (-$2.29)
Dell Technologies Inc. Class C
11:55 AM
$74.96
DLTR
-1.74% (-$1.33)
Dollar Tree, Inc.
11:55 AM
$69.39
EBAY
-0.10% (-$0.07)
eBay Inc.
11:55 AM
$116.40
EXPD
-0.73% (-$0.86)
Expeditors International of Washington, Inc.
12:05 PM
$74.78
FAST
-0.48% (-$0.36)
Fastenal Company
12:10 PM
$40.36
FLEX
-3.19% (-$1.33)
Flex Ltd.
12:00 PM
$109.95
GILD
-0.07% (-$0.08)
Gilead Sciences, Inc.
12:10 PM
$24.37
GNTX
-0.89% (-$0.22)
Gentex Corporation
12:00 PM
$224.71
GRMN
-1.88% (-$4.30)
Garmin Ltd.
12:05 PM
$77.24
HSIC
-1.04% (-$0.81)
Henry Schein, Inc.
12:40 PM
$565.47
INTU
-2.35% (-$13.61)
Intuit Inc.
12:05 PM
$35.99
JNPR
-0.22% (-$0.08)
Juniper Networks, Inc.
12:15 PM
$754.30
KLAC
-3.00% (-$23.33)
KLA Corporation
12:40 PM
$121.91
LAMR
-0.33% (-$0.40)
Lamar Advertising Company
4:40 PM
$86.02
LRCX
-3.37% (-$3.00)
Lam Research Corporation
12:15 PM
$61.07
MCHP
-5.02% (-$3.23)
Microchip Technology Incorporated
12:05 PM
$26.95
MEDI
-1.89% (-$0.52)
Harbor
11:55 AM
$103.81
MRVL
-4.51% (-$4.90)
Marvell Technology, Inc.
12:40 PM
$124.47
NTAP
-0.06% (-$0.08)
NetApp, Inc.
12:40 PM
$148.51
PAYX
-1.16% (-$1.75)
Paychex, Inc.
12:05 PM
$104.46
PCAR
-1.88% (-$2.00)
PACCAR Inc.
12:00 PM
$31.07
PDCO
0.03% ($0.01)
Patterson Companies, Inc.
11:50 AM
$8.34
PTEN
-5.55% (-$0.49)
Patterson-UTI Energy, Inc.
11:50 AM
$165.43
QCOM
-4.76% (-$8.27)
QUALCOMM Incorporated
11:50 AM
$136.61
ROST
-1.78% (-$2.48)
Ross Stores, Inc.
12:05 PM
$45.16
RYAAY
-0.81% (-$0.37)
Ryanair Holdings plc
12:00 PM
$64.89
SANM
-0.22% (-$0.15)
Sanmina Corporation
6:26 PM
$75.90
SBUX
0.30% ($0.22)
Starbucks Corporation
6:26 PM
$554.84
SNPS
0.90% ($4.96)
Synopsys, Inc.
6:26 PM
$293.64
SPOT
-1.68% (-$5.02)
Spotify Technology S.A. Ordinary
6:26 PM
$16.33
TEVA
2.09% ($0.33)
Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Limited American Depositary
6:26 PM
$171.31
VRSN
0.90% ($1.52)
VeriSign, Inc.
6:26 PM
$231.27
VRTS
-1.39% (-$3.27)
Virtus Investment Partners, Inc.
6:26 PM
$28.00
XRAY
-0.71% (-$0.20)
DENTSPLY SIRONA Inc.
6:26 PM
$
BRK.B
% (-$)
Berkshire Hathaway Inc. New
$38.42
BAC
0.35% ($0.14)
Bank of America Corporation
6:26 PM
$153.50
PEP
2.95% ($4.40)
PepsiCo, Inc.
12:05 PM
$134.92
ABT
1.31% ($1.75)
Abbott Laboratories
11:50 AM
$532.55
TMO
-0.98% (-$5.28)
Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc
11:55 AM
$218.66
AVGO
-3.56% (-$8.08)
Broadcom Inc.
12:10 PM
$364.26
ACN
-5.35% (-$20.58)
Accenture plc
12:00 PM
$873.68
LLY
0.06% ($0.56)
Eli Lilly and Company
12:05 PM
$210.23
DHR
1.10% ($2.28)
Danaher Corporation
11:55 AM
$89.94
MDT
2.27% ($2.00)
Medtronic plc. Ordinary
11:45 AM
$71.58
NEE
2.05% ($1.44)
NextEra Energy, Inc.
11:55 AM
$202.00
TXN
-0.96% (-$1.96)
Texas Instruments Incorporated
12:00 PM
$458.00
LIN
-0.84% (-$3.90)
Linde plc
11:55 AM
$55.83
BMY
0.07% ($0.04)
Bristol-Myers Squibb Company
11:55 AM
$77.50
WFC
-1.44% (-$1.13)
Wells Fargo & Company
11:45 AM
$154.40
PM
1.87% ($2.83)
Philip Morris International Inc
12:10 PM
$245.55
UNP
-0.85% (-$2.10)
Union Pacific Corporation
11:55 AM
$261.48
IBM
-1.23% (-$3.26)
International Business Machines Corporation
12:00 PM
$131.69
MS
-1.97% (-$2.65)
Morgan Stanley
11:45 AM
$199.83
GE
-4.27% (-$8.91)
GE Aerospace
12:00 PM
$340.04
CAT
-2.61% (-$9.11)
Caterpillar, Inc.
11:50 AM
$974.22
BLK
-1.53% (-$15.16)
BlackRock, Inc.
12:00 PM
$55.05
MO
1.33% ($0.72)
Altria Group, Inc.
12:15 AM
$116.33
UPS
-0.23% (-$0.27)
United Parcel Service, Inc.
12:05 PM
$489.98
DE
-1.17% (-$5.81)
Deere & Company
11:55 AM
$79.65
C
-2.08% (-$1.69)
Citigroup, Inc.
12:00 PM
$440.72
LMT
1.02% ($4.43)
Lockheed Martin Corporation
12:00 PM
$123.29
RTX
-0.96% (-$1.19)
RTX Corporation
11:55 AM
$69.85
FIS
0.00% (-$0.00)
Fidelity National Information Services, Inc.
11:45 AM
$591.79
ISRG
-2.44% (-$14.78)
Intuitive Surgical, Inc.
12:05 PM
$382.78
SYK
-0.94% (-$3.63)
Stryker Corporation
12:10 PM
$80.44
SCHW
-1.70% (-$1.39)
Charles Schwab Corporation (The)
11:55 AM
$299.81
CI
0.04% ($0.13)
The Cigna Group
11:50 AM
$484.24
VRTX
0.81% ($3.91)
Vertex Pharmaceuticals Incorporated
12:00 PM
$227.43
BDX
-0.22% (-$0.50)
Becton, Dickinson and Company
12:00 PM
$533.40
SPGI
-0.38% (-$2.03)
S&P Global Inc.
12:00 PM
$98.84
MU
-4.21% (-$4.34)
Micron Technology, Inc.
12:10 PM
$188.05
PNC
-2.00% (-$3.84)
PNC Financial Services Group, Inc.
11:50 AM
$9.28
F
-1.17% (-$0.11)
Ford Motor Company
12:00 PM
$124.27
TGT
-3.01% (-$3.86)
Target Corporation
11:55 AM
$310.76
ADP
-0.39% (-$1.21)
Automatic Data Processing, Inc.
11:45 AM
$71.80
EL
0.64% ($0.46)
Estee Lauder Companies, Inc.
12:05 PM
$239.17
LOW
-2.94% (-$7.25)
Lowe's Companies, Inc.
11:55 AM
$97.94
COP
-3.98% (-$4.06)
ConocoPhillips
12:00 PM
$267.25
CB
-0.09% (-$0.24)
Chubb Limited
11:50 AM
$64.67
MDLZ
4.02% ($2.50)
Mondelez International, Inc.
3:25 AM
$133.08
EOG
-1.91% (-$2.59)
EOG Resources, Inc.
12:10 PM
$121.11
TJX
-1.52% (-$1.87)
TJX Companies, Inc.
11:55 AM
$4990.64
BKNG
-0.55% (-$27.59)
Booking Holdings Inc.
5:40 PM
$76.65
AIG
0.52% ($0.40)
American International Group, Inc.
12:10 PM
$46.29
GM
-3.34% (-$1.60)
General Motors Company
12:00 PM
$60.00
DAL
-5.88% (-$3.75)
Delta Air Lines, Inc.
11:55 AM
$104.83
ZBH
1.16% ($1.20)
Zimmer Biomet Holdings, Inc.
12:05 PM
$89.47
CL
1.82% ($1.60)
Colgate-Palmolive Company
12:15 AM
$500.28
MCO
-2.22% (-$11.34)
Moody's Corporation
11:50 AM
$81.01
MET
-2.09% (-$1.73)
MetLife, Inc.
11:55 AM
$34.63
HPQ
-0.26% (-$0.09)
HP Inc.
11:45 AM
$38.25
FMC
0.16% ($0.06)
FMC Corporation
12:00 PM
$140.26
KMB
0.93% ($1.29)
Kimberly-Clark Corporation
12:00 PM
$48.19
ADM
3.52% ($1.64)
Archer-Daniels-Midland Company
12:10 PM
$76.69
DG
0.74% ($0.56)
Dollar General Corporation
12:00 PM
$255.91
HUM
-5.67% (-$15.39)
Humana Inc.
11:50 AM